Table 5. Indicator <B-1> Fidelity of collecting opinions.

Indicator Policy-making >> Appropriateness of policy-making process > Fidelity of collecting opinions
Description Check whether the opinions of internal and external experts were collected when making the policy
Question Did the opinions of internal and external experts for policy-making be collected and reflected in the policy?
Check criteria Measure Score Opinion gathering method Experts participation Level of policy reflection
Very good 4 When conduct at least one of five methods (public hearing, debate, meeting, council, survey) Both internal and external experts Convergence results are reflected in policy-making
Good 3 When conduct at least one of five methods Both internal and external experts Convergence results are NOT reflected in policy-making
Acceptable 2 When conduct at least one of five methods Only internal or external experts Convergence results are reflected in policy-making
Poor 1 When conduct at least one of five methods Only internal or external experts Convergence results are NOT reflected in policy-making
Very poor 0 When NO conduct five methods - -
Source of data - Public hearing, debate, meeting, council, and survey material created during policy-making- List of experts who participated in policy-making (including profiles) and documented expert opinion- Result report showing the policy-making reflection items (e.g., Project Closure Report)