Description | Check whether a systematic analysis was performed when making the policy |
Question | Have you conducted the core analysis (effect analysis, pros and cons analysis) and additional analysis (other analysis besides the core analysis) to make the policy? |
Check criteria | Measure | Score | Core analysis (effect analysis) | Core analysis (pros and cons analysis) | Additional analysis |
Very good | 4 | When conduct an effect analysis such as benefit cost analysis | When conduct a pros and cons analysis such as SWOT analysis | When conduct an additional quantitative and qualitative analysis |
Good | 3 | When conduct an effect analysis such as benefit cost analysis | When conduct a pros and cons analysis such as SWOT analysis | When NO conduct an additional quantitative and qualitative analysis |
Acceptable | 2 | When either an effect analysis or a pros and cons analysis is conducted | When conduct additional quantitative and qualitative analysis |
Poor | 1 | When either an effect analysis or a pros and cons analysis is conducted | When NO conduct additional quantitative and qualitative analysis |
When neither an effect analysis nor a pros and cons analysis is conducted | When conduct additional quantitative and qualitative analysis |
Very poor | 0 | When neither an effect analysis nor a pros and cons analysis is conducted | When NO conduct additional quantitative and qualitative analysis |
* Note. If a simple expert survey or interview is used, it is interpreted as additional analysis. |
Source of data | - Result of effect analysis (benefit cost analysis), pros and cons analysis, etc.- Expert survey / interview output (document and recorded file) for policy-making- Requirement institution document for informatization project |